1. Pururin
  2. Contribute
  3. Twin Mother Encirclement? / お母さん包囲網 [G39102]
Pending Contributions
Upload My Contributions
Add New Tag

Edit for: Twin Mother Encirclement? / お母さん包囲網 [G39102]

S28806
Current Suggested
English Twin Mother Encirclement? Twin Mother Encirclement?
Japanese お母さん包囲網 お母さん包囲網
Alternative Okaa-san Houimou Okaa-san Houimou
Description - -
Content tags
Contribution Information
Submitted by: beStrange
Submitted on: Feb 02, 2020 at 05:26:53
Last updated: Feb 02, 2020 at 05:29:21
Status: Rejected
Note: -
Gallery: Twin Mother Encirclement? / お母さん包囲網

Should this contribution be approved?

5 comments (0 hidden)

0
beStrange
Glovelove i don't understand the rejection, both woman are Drunk / 酔っぱらい and give perform Paizuri / パイズリ on the boy...
0
Glovelove
seems I overlooked the single page of Paizuri when I checked so figured only drunk applied, though I admit there's some confirmation bias involved when I check anything uploaded by Shirou because he's the last person I'd expect to get anything wrong in that department. having seen that there is a brief double titjob I'll add Paizuri as well then as I really can't be assed to start an argument about pressence rules (how much screentime a tag would need to apply) right after Shirou updates the tagging guide to imply we're really loose on that... (which he did in response to finding out I was really strict on that when editing myself, though a lot laxer when it comes to moderation)
0
beStrange
>>147016 @ Glovelove
ah okay... i'll keep "the amount of panels" in mind in the future... and no, i didn't want to start an argument, just wanted to know the reason for the rejection so that i can apply it to future edits
0
Glovelove
yeah, just to be clear, the amount of panels is mostly a matter of feeling of gut anyway, that's why I tend to give a lot more leeway on it when moderating then when editing. Would be a percentage more than a hard guideline but it also really varies per tag as impregnation for example doesn't take much screentime in general, just an orgasm and confirmation that it impregnated can happen within a single page. Then there's some extreme stuff like Scat where it has to be applied if even a single panel shows it, I suspect we have a lot of loli content where it doesn't really apply because Loli is one of those tags on sadpanda but its not for us (though toddlercon should be I'm not 100% sure if that's the case).

the general guideline to keep in mind is "if I blacklisted tag X, would seeing it in this gallery ruin the whole thing for me" (which is why snuff/guro and the "bathroom kinks" have this 1panel thing) and for more specific fetishes "would someone liking/tag searching this tag be satisfied with how much screentime it really got". that last one is what sparked an argument between Shirou and me because I feel ripped off when I see a green border on a tank then read 150 pages of stuff that doesn't interest me to find out the mind control tag is given for just a single chapter pretty far in, but according to him it is A-okay on screentime if 18 pages in a 220 page tank are relevant for the tag......

Keep up the good work, glad to have others helping me out with tagging, you've been doing enough that seeing an upvote/downvote on pending contributions from you effectively saves me the effort of reading myself when it comes to contextual tags like NTR I'd otherwise just procrastinate reading for XD
0
beStrange
i can see both sides of that argument, it sucks that you have to go through a lot of pages to find the tagged content... but not having the content tagged at all sucks as well, especially if one runs into something later on that is a total turn off for the reader

anyways, thank you for trusting my opinion, i'll try to keep that trust ;)

Linking: To prevent spam, all links are stripped out of your comment.

You can link internally to galleries, users, tags, etc. by typing an identifier (consisting of one letter and a number) between brackets. To quickly find and select tags and galleries to link to, use the searchfield to insert them into your post.

Examples:
  • Reply to a post: eg. [C5]
  • Link to a tag: eg. [T187]
  • Link to a gallery: eg. [G54]
  • Link to an image: eg. [G54#2]
  • Link to a user: eg. [U521]
  • Link to a contribution: eg. [S128]
  • Link to a forum post: eg. [P15]